All-Orange County
| 1990 | ||
| Trevor Yankoff | OC Register - 1st GTE/Rams All-Academic |
P |
| David Shearer | GTE/Rams All-Academic | WR |
| Ron Mehrens | All-Academic | TE |
| 1991 | ||
| Jimmy Herlehy | OC Register | OL |
| Josh Ireland | OC Register | RB |
| Matt Zaist | GTE/Rams All-Academic | OL |
| 1992 | ||
| Brian Finneran | OC Register | WR |
| Sean O'Brien | OC Register | QB |
| 1993 | ||
| Brad Finneran | LA Times - 1st OC Register |
DB |
| Brian Finneran | LA Times - 1st OC Register |
WR |
| 1994 | ||
| Kris Farris | LA Times - 1st | OL |
| Rik Glover | LA Times - 2nd | DL |
| 1995 | ||
| Brian Berg | DL | |
| 1996 | ||
| Billy Newman | OC Register - 2nd LA Times - 2nd |
RB |
| Stan Bennett | OC Register - 2nd LA Times - 2nd |
OL |
| Damien Minna | OC Register - 2nd | LB |
| John Minardi | OC Register - 2nd | WR |
| 1997 | ||
| John Minardi | OC Register - 1st LA Times - 1st |
WR |
| Carson Palmer | OC Register - 1st LA Times - 1st |
QB |
| Nick Cappelletti | LA Times - 1st | LB |
| Ryan Mannix | OC Register - 1st | OL |
| Nick Sparks | OC Register - 2nd LA Times - 2nd |
K |
| Matt Strickroth | OC Register - 2nd LA Times - 2nd |
DL |
| Bryant Wolfsberger | OC Register - 2nd | RB |
| 1998 | ||
| Will Watson | LA Times - 2nd | DL |
| Mike O'Gorman | OC Register - 2nd | WR |
| 2000 | ||
| Ryan Lumm | OC Register LA Times |
OL |
| Tyler Thompson | OC Register LA Times - 2nd |
LB/RB |
| Alex Huston | OC Register | DL |
| 2001 | ||
| Mike Tirabassi | OC Register - 1st | OL |
| Ashton White | OC Register - 1st LA Times |
RB DB |
| Mike Leiter | OC Register - 1st | DL |
| John Finneran | OC Register - 2nd | OL |
| 2002 | ||
| Matt Rupp | OC Register - 1st | DL |
| Bobby Whithorne | LA Times - 1st | WR |
| 2003 | ||
| Matt Rupp | OC Register - 1st LA Times |
DL |
| 2005 | ||
| Tom Roby | OC Register - 1st | OL |
| 2006 | ||
| Mike Jacot | OC Register - 1st LA Times |
Coach of the Year |
| Ryan Maxwell | OC Register - 1st | DB |
| Logan Harrell | OC Register - 1st | DT |
| 2007 | ||
| Logan Harrell | OC Register - 1st | DT |
| 2009 | ||
| Harry Welch | OC Register | Coach of the Year |
| Troy Willett | OC Register - 2nd | LB |
| 2010 | ||
| Harry Welch | OC Register - 1st LA Times |
Coach of the Year |
| Adam Young | OC Register - 1st | QB |
| Max Tuerk | OC Register - 1st LA Times |
OL |
| Colten Christensen | OC Register - 1st | LB |
| Kyle McPherson | OC Register - 2nd | OL |
| Emmett O'Brien | OC Register - 3rd | LB |
| 2011 | ||
| Johnny Stanton | OC Register - 1st ESPN LA - OC Player of the Year |
All-Purpose QB |
| Connor O'Brien | OC Register - 1st ESPN LA - 1st |
WR |
| Chris Frost | OC Register - 1st ESPN LA - 1st |
DL |
| Riley Sorenson | OC Register - 1st | OL |
| Max Tuerk | OC Register - 1st ESPN LA - 1st LA Times |
OL |
| Ryan Wolpin | OC Register - 1st ESPN LA - 1st |
RB |
| John McGrory | OC Register - 1st ESPN LA - 1st |
K |
| Dane Crane | OC Register - 2nd | OL |
| Mack Pierson | OC Register - 2nd | DL |
| Matt Andersen | OC Register - 2nd | LB |
| 2012 | ||
| Connor O'Brien | OC Register - 1st | DB |
| Dane Crane | OC Register - 1st LA Times |
OL |
| River Cracraft | OC Register - 1st | WR |
| 2013 | ||
| Kyle Sweet | OC Register - 2nd | All-Purpose |
| Ryan Kilander | OC Register - 2nd | OL |
| Jonathan LaBonty | OC Register - 3rd LA Times |
DB |
| 2014 | ||
| Austin Maihen | OC Register - 1st LA Times |
OL |
| Kyle Sweet | OC Register - 1st | Offensive Specialist |
| Rick Ellison | OC Register - 1st | DB |
| Rick Wade | OC Register - 2nd LA Times |
DL |
| Grady Higgins | OC Register - 2nd | LB |
| KJ Costello | OC Register - 3rd | QB |
| 2015 | ||
| Alec Stewart | OC Register - 1st | DL |
| Sam Loy | OC Register - 1st | Punter |
| Tanner Matthews | OC Register - 1st | LB |
| 2016 | ||
| Brett Neilon | OC Register - 1st LA Times - 1st |
OL |
| Chad Magyar | OC Register - 2nd | RB |
| Grant Calcaterra | OC Register - 2nd | WR |
| Malone Mataele | OC Register - 2nd | All-Purpose |
| Caden Fitch | OC Register - 3rd | LB |
| 2017 | ||
| Chad Magyar | OC Register - 1st | RB |
| Dylan Brady | OC Register - 1st | K |
| Malone Mataele | OC Register - 2nd | All-Purpose |
| Caden Fitch | OC Register - 2nd | LB |
| 2018 | ||
| Chase Nenad | OC Register - 3rd | WR |
| 2019 | ||
| Derek Wilkins | OC Register - 2nd | DL |
| 2020 | ||
| Hero Kanu | LA Times - 1st | DL |
| 2021 | ||
| Hero Kanu | OC Register - 1st LA Times - 1st |
DL |
| Kilian O'Connor | OC Register - 1st | OL |
| Blake Wilson | OC Register - 2nd | DB |
| Romen Christensen | OC Register - 2nd | P |
| Niko Lopez | OC Register - 3rd | WR |
| 2022 | ||
| Emmett Mosley | OC Register - 1st | WR |
| Jalani Liva | OC Register - 2nd | OL |
| Jacob Bower | OC Register - 2nd | LB |
| Jaxon Potter | OC Register - 3rd | QB |
| Donovan Comestro | OC Register - 3rd | DB |
| 2023 | ||
| Trent Mosley | OC Register - 1st | WR |
| Jacob Maiava | OC Register - 2nd | OL |
| Noah Sulick | OC Register - 2nd | LB |
| Levar Talley | OC Register - 3rd | DL |
