All-League
| 1989 - Olympic League | ||
| Nathan Beckett | OL | |
| Mike Farris | LB | |
| Josh Ireland | RB | |
| David Shearer | WR | |
| Shane Mielke | OL | |
| Eric Brown | DB | |
| Ryan Mummert | LB | |
| Trevor Yankoff | QB | |
| 1990 | ||
| Freelance Schedule | ||
| 1991 | ||
| Freelance Schedule | ||
| 1992 - Sea View League | ||
| Brent Noonan | OL | |
| Brad Finneran | WR | |
| Brian Finneran | WR | |
| Sean O'Brien | QB | |
| Chris Tiernan | LB | |
| Kevin Duffy | DB | |
| Tom Dickson | 2nd | OL |
| Tom Haupert | 2nd | OL |
| 1993 - Sea View League | ||
| Frank Brenes | OL | |
| Brad Finneran | WR | |
| Brian Finneran | WR | |
| Derek Yankoff | Utility | |
| Chris Collins | LB | |
| Rik Glover | DL | |
| Kris Farris | 2nd | OL |
| 1994 - Sea View League | ||
| Josh Beckett | OL | |
| Brian Berg | DL | |
| Rik Glover | DL | |
| Ryan Korinke | K | |
| Matt Nickels | DB | |
| Eric Brown | 2nd | TE |
| Chris Collins | 2nd | QB |
| Kris Farris | 2nd | OL |
| Brian Griffin | 2nd | DB |
| Matt Lucas | 2nd | LB |
| Billy Newman | 2nd | RB |
| 1995 - Sea View League | ||
| Brian Berg | DL | |
| Chris Collins | QB | |
| Billy Newman | RB | |
| Matt Nickels | WR | |
| Gregg Pichler | DB | |
| Eric Brown | 2nd | TE |
| Matt Baier | 2nd | DL |
| Billy O'Connor | 2nd | DB |
| 1996 - Sea View League | ||
| Billy Newman | MVP Offense | RB |
| Damien Minna | MVP Defense | LB |
| Jim Hartigan | Coach of the Year | HC |
| Carson Palmer | QB | |
| Stan Bennett | OL | |
| Shaun Jackson | OL | |
| John Minardi | WR | |
| Matt Strickroth | DL | |
| Brett Crowder | DB | |
| Andrew Holstein | LB | |
| Bryce Jackson | 2nd | OL |
| Austin Jayred | 2nd | DL |
| Andy Hopper | 2nd | DL |
| Jason Rowell | 2nd | DL |
| Matt Brooks | 2nd | DB |
| Nick Sparks | 2nd | K |
| 1997 - Sea View League | ||
| Carson Palmer | MVP Offense | QB |
| John Minardi | MVP Defense | DB |
| Nick Sparks | MVP Kicker | K |
| Jim Hartigan | Coach of the Year | HC |
| Bryant Wolfsberger | RB | |
| Ryan Mannix | OL | |
| Greg Orlando | WR | |
| Jason Rowell | DL | |
| Matt Strickroth | OL | |
| Nick Cappelletti | LB | |
| Andrew Holstein | LB | |
| Jordan Beckner | 2nd | TE |
| Shaun Jackson | 2nd | OL |
| Jarlath Curran | 2nd | OL |
| Andy Hopper | 2nd | DL |
| Matt Brooks | 2nd | DB |
| Jesse Wyatt | 2nd | LB |
| 1998 - Sea View League | ||
| Mike O'Gorman | WR | |
| Greg Orlando | QB | |
| Spencer McCroskey | RB | |
| Josh Wills | LB | |
| Will Watson | DL | |
| Collin Rooke | 2nd | DL |
| Tyler Thompson | 2nd | DB |
| Greg Samuels | 2nd | OL |
| Matt Lopez | 2nd | WR |
| 1999 - Serra League | ||
| Ryan Lumm | OL | |
| Matt Vogel | LB | |
| Jimmy Herzog | RB | |
| Tyler Thompson | DB | |
| John Cappelletti | 2nd | DL |
| David Doomey | 2nd | WR |
| Trent Zinn | 2nd | DB |
| Chris Rix | 2nd | WR |
| Jimmy Whithorne | 2nd | LB |
| 2000 - Serra League | ||
| Tyler Thompson | MVP | RB/LB |
| Ryan Lumm | OL | |
| Ashton White | RB | |
| Curtis Cooper | WR | |
| Matt Vogel | LB | |
| Alex Huston | DL | |
| Trevor Zinn | DB | |
| Thomas Cappelletti | DB | |
| Mike Tirabassi | 2nd | OL |
| Johnnie Walker | 2nd | WR |
| Doug Alvarado | 2nd | DL |
| Spencer Hollison | 2nd | OL |
| Kyle Skierski | 2nd | OL |
| Chad Brazee | 2nd | DL |
| Chris Cutler | 2nd | DL |
| Ryan Whelan | 2nd | RB |
| Matt Dlugolecki | 2nd | QB |
| 2001 - Serra League | ||
| Ashton White | MVP | RB/DB |
| Marshall Tharpe | MVP Offense | QB |
| Mike Tirabassi | OL | |
| John Finneran | OL | |
| Bobby Whithorne | WR | |
| Renny Jackson | WR | |
| Michael Leiter | DL | |
| Brad Dillahunty | DL | |
| Kyle Rutenbar | LB | |
| Cole DeVitis | DB | |
| Thomas Cappelletti | DB | |
| Trevor Zinn | DB | |
| Leif Nylander | P | |
| Nick Corrado | 2nd | OL |
| Spencer Hollison | 2nd | OL |
| Dustin Slinkard | 2nd | TE |
| Travis Widner | 2nd | RB |
| Matt Rupp | 2nd | DL |
| Jeff Prenovost | 2nd | LB |
| Jack Meehan | 2nd | LB |
| 2002 - Serra League | ||
| Matt Rupp | DL | |
| Bobby Whithorne | WR | |
| Ashton White | 2nd | RB |
| Ryan Nienhuis | 2nd | DB |
| 2003 - Serra League | ||
| Matt Rupp | Co-MVP Defense | DL |
| Michael Angelo | QB | |
| Ryan Neinhaus | WR | |
| Jack Meehan | LB | |
| Mark Restelli | DB | |
| Nick Bahr | 2nd | OL |
| Stephan Strickroth | 2nd | OL |
| Thomas Ramirez | 2nd | LB |
| Jeff Jones | 2nd | DL |
| 2004 - Serra League | ||
| Jon Daniels | QB | |
| Mason Frakes | OL | |
| Michael Rusert | LB | |
| Ross Cumming | DL | |
| Jacob Gordon | 2nd | WR |
| Kyle Bryant | 2nd | WR |
| Tom Roby | 2nd | DL |
| J.D. Dawson | 2nd | DB |
| 2005 - Serra League | ||
| Tom Roby | MVP Lineman | OL |
| John Angelo | RB | |
| Jon Daniels | QB | |
| Ryan Maxwell | WR | |
| J.D. Dawson | DB | |
| Thomas Hull | Punter | |
| Matt Bahr | 2nd | OL |
| Brad Dixon | 2nd | OL |
| Jacob Gordon | 2nd | WR |
| Kyle Aldridge | 2nd | LB |
| Ross Cumming | 2nd | LB |
| Andrew Johnson | 2nd | DL |
| 2006 - Trinity League | ||
| Ryan Maxwell | MVP Offense | WR/DB |
| Eric Reisinger | QB | |
| Charles Taylor | OL | |
| Kyle Aldridge | LB | |
| Matt Browning | DL/TE | |
| Chris Spangenberg | 2nd | RB |
| Andrew Hanson | 2nd | OL |
| Bobby Collins | 2nd | OL |
| Mike Lacy | 2nd | LB |
| Matt Meyer | 2nd | DB |
| Logan Harrell | 2nd | DL |
| 2007 - Trinity League | ||
| Carlo Audagnotti | MVP Offense | RB |
| Trevor Brooks | RB | |
| Declan Escobar | OL | |
| Kirk Skierski | LB | |
| Logan Harrell | DL | |
| Nick Wagner | Punter | |
| Ryan Gotschall | 2nd | WR |
| Chris Parr | 2nd | OL |
| A.J. Cruz | 2nd | DB |
| Brett Haness | 2nd | DB |
| 2008 - Trinity League | ||
| AJ Cruz | DB | |
| Sean Willet | WR | |
| Ryan World | QB | |
| Troy Willett | LB | |
| Gavin Escobar | 2nd | WR |
| Logan Sweet | 2nd | QB |
| Justin Bennett | 2nd | DL |
| Andrew Spangenberg | 2nd | DL |
| 2009 - Trinity League | ||
| Tom Chiarello | OL | |
| Troy Willet | LB | |
| Andrew Spangenberg | LB | |
| Spencer Tyson | RB | |
| Max Tuerk | 2nd | TE |
| Reiley Higgins | 2nd | WR |
| Doug Woodward | 2nd | DL |
| Matt Andersen | 2nd | LB |
| 2010 - Trinity League | ||
| Max Tuerk | MVP Lineman | OL |
| Colten Christensen | MVP Defense | LB |
| Adam Young | QB | |
| Kyle McPherson | OL | |
| Cory Thomson | RB | |
| Doug Woodward | LB | |
| Jeff Emanuel | WR | |
| Emmett O'Brien | DB | |
| Reiley Higgins | 2nd | WR |
| River Cracraft | 2nd | WR |
| Logan Sweet | 2nd | WR |
| Johnnhy Stanton | 2nd | DB |
| Nick Owens | 2nd | DB |
| Eric Feucht | 2nd | DL |
| 2011 - Trinity League | ||
| Johnny Stanton | Co-MVP Offense | QB |
| Max Tuerk | Co-MVP Lineman | OL |
| Chris Frost | Co-MVP Defense | DL |
| Ryan Wolpin | RB | |
| Dane Crane | OL | |
| Riley Sorenson | OL | |
| John McGrory | K | |
| Connor O’Brien | DB | |
| Mack Pierson | DL | |
| Matt Andersen | LB | |
| Sean Modster | 2nd | WR |
| Cole Luther | 2nd | OL |
| Alex Suchesk | 2nd | RB |
| RJ Mazolewski | 2nd | DB |
| Sammy Gibbs | 2nd | LB |
| Sean Donegan | 2nd | DL |
| 2012 - Trinity League | ||
| River Cracraft | Co-MVP Offense | WR |
| Dane Crane | Co-MVP Lineman | OL |
| Riley Sorenson | OL | |
| Ryan Wolpin | RB | |
| Connor O'Brien | DB | |
| R.J. Mazolewski | DB | |
| Kyle Sweet | 2nd | WR |
| Ryan Kilander | 2nd | OL |
| Frank DiPietro | 2nd | OL |
| Sammy Gibbs | 2nd | LB |
| Nick Begg | 2nd | DL |
| Tony Bone | 2nd | LB |
| 2013 - Trinity League | ||
| Kyle Sweet | WR | |
| Ryan Kilander | OL | |
| Jonathon LaBonty | DB | |
| Rick Wade | DL | |
| Jeremy McNichols | 2nd | RB |
| Drake Schwenke | 2nd | OL |
| Grady Higgins | 2nd | LB |
| Alec McNiff | 2nd | DB |
| 2014 - Trinity League | ||
| KJ Costello | Co-MVP Offense | QB |
| Rick Wade | Co-MVP Lineman | DL |
| Kyle Sweet | WR | |
| Austin Maihen | OL | |
| Rick Ellison | DB | |
| Grady Higgins | LB | |
| Conner Bianchini | 2nd | WR |
| Tanner Prenovost | 2nd | OL |
| Stash Rowley | 2nd | DL |
| JP Hackett | 2nd | DB |
| 2015 - Trinity League | ||
| Alec Stewart | Co-MVP Defense | DL |
| Sam Loy | MVP Punter | K |
| Grant Calcaterra | WR | |
| KJ Costello | QB | |
| Matt Mark | LB | |
| Tanner Matthews | LB | |
| Tanner Prenovost | 2nd | OL |
| Dylan Crawford | 2nd | WR |
| Noah Canty | 2nd | DB |
| Chris Levici | 2nd | DL |
| 2016 - Trinity League | ||
| Brett Neilon | OL | |
| Grant Calcaterra | WR | |
| Caden Fitch | LB | |
| Malone Mataele | DB/KR/PR | |
| Richard Wagner | 2nd | QB |
| Chad Magyar | 2nd | RB |
| 2017 - Trinity League | ||
| Dylan Brady | MVP Kicker | K |
| Malone Mataele | MVP Specialist | WR/DB/KR/PR |
| Chad Magyar | RB | |
| Josiah Norwood | QB | |
| Caden Fitch | LB | |
| John McCartan | DL | |
| Jake Peters | 2nd | TE |
| Mark Eaton | 2nd | WR |
| Chris Gonzalez | 2nd | OL |
| Sean Toohey | 2nd | LB |
| Quentin Buchman | 2nd | DB |
| Alex Kilander | 2nd | DL |
| 2018 - Trinity League | ||
| Jake Thomas | RB | |
| Chase Nenad | WR | |
| Matt Hartigan | LB | |
| Blake Bianchini | DB | |
| Peter Costelli | 2nd | QB |
| Matt Kilander | 2nd | OL |
| Greg Doyle | 2nd | DL |
| Logan Schwenke | 2nd | DL |
| 2019 - Trinity League | ||
| Nick Barcelos | RB/LS | |
| Kilian O'Connor | OL | |
| Derek Wilkins | DL | |
| Drew Sulick | LB | |
| Tyler Hartigan | 2nd | DL |
| Mark Ard Jr. | 2nd | DB |
| William Oberholtzer | 2nd | DL |
| Ian Grogan | 2nd | WR |
| 2020 - Trinity League | ||
| Drew Sulick | LB/S | |
| Derek Wilkins | DL | |
| Hero Kanu | DL | |
| Colt Fulton | QB | |
| Michael Buckley | WR | |
| Reymello Murphy | WR | |
| Kilian O'Connor | 2nd | OL |
| Jalen Jones | 2nd | WR |
| Niko Lopez | 2nd | WR |
| Donovan Comestro | 2nd | DB |
| Maurice Heims | 2nd | DL |
| Blake Wilson | 2nd | DB |
| 2021 - Trinity League | ||
| Romen Christensen | Co-Punter of the Year | K |
| Kilian O'Connor | OL | |
| Jalen Jones | WR | |
| Niko Lopez | WR | |
| Donovan Comestro | DB | |
| Blake Wilson | DB | |
| Hero Kanu | DL | |
| Joe Becerra | 2nd | OL |
| Jalani Liva | 2nd | OL |
| Jaxon Potter | 2nd | QB |
| Romen Christensen | 2nd | LB |
| Jake Bower | 2nd | LB |
| LeVar Talley | 2nd | DL |
| 2022 - Trinity League | ||
| Jaxon Potter | QB | |
| Emmett Mosley | WR | |
| Niko Lopez | WR | |
| Donovan Comestro | DB | |
| Jake Bower | LB | |
| LeVar Talley | DL | |
| Jalani Liva | 2nd | OL |
| Bain Eiseman | 2nd | WR |
| Trent Mosley | 2nd | WR |
| Josh Tuchek | 2nd | DB |
| Gage Burnett | 2nd | DL |
| Noah Sulick | 2nd | LB |
| 2023 - Trinity League | ||
| Trent Mosley | Co-MVP | WR |
| Noah Sulick | LB | |
| Gage Burnett | LB | |
| Skylar Lendsey | RB | |
| Jacob Maiava | OL | |
| LeVar Talley | 2nd | LB |
| Aleki Manutai | 2nd | DL |
| Grant Degulis | 2nd | OL |
| Ethan Thomas | 2nd | OL |
| 2024 - Trinity League | ||
| Dash Fifita | Co-Defensive MVP | LB |
| Trent Mosley | WR | |
| Sean Embree | WR | |
| Jack Junker | WR | |
| Aleki Holani | LB | |
| Luke Anderson | DB | |
| Jayden Crowder | DB | |
| Jaion Duce Smith | 2nd | RB |
| John Gazzaniga | 2nd | QB |
| Elijah Vaikona | 2nd | OL |
| Logan Hirou | 2nd | DB |
| JJ Hanne | 2nd | DL |
| Siua Holani | 2nd | DB |
