All-CIF
| 1989 - Division IX | |
| Mike Farris | LB |
| Josh Ireland | RB |
| 1990 - Division IV | |
| Mike Farris | LB |
| Josh Ireland | RB |
| Trevor Yankoff | QB |
| 1991 - Division V | |
| Sean O'Brien | DB |
| Josh Ireland | RB |
| 1992 - Division IV | |
| Brad Finneran | WR |
| Brian Finneran | WR |
| Sean O'Brien | QB |
| 1993 - Division IV | |
| Brad Finneran | WR |
| Brian Finneran | WR |
| 1994 - Division V | |
| Josh Beckett | OL |
| Rik Glover | DL |
| 1995 - Division V | |
| Brian Berg | DL |
| 1996 - ALL-CIF-SS TEAM (The best from all 12 S.S. Divisions) | |
| Damien Minna - 2nd Team | LB |
| Stan Bennett - 2nd Team | OL |
| 1996 - Division V | |
| Jim Hartigan - Coach of the Year | Head Coach |
| Billy Newman - Offensive MVP | RB |
| Damien Minna - Defensive MVP | LB |
| Stan Bennett | OL |
| John Minardi | WR |
| Austin Jayred | DL |
| Brett Crowder | DB |
| 1997 - ALL-CIF-SS TEAM (The best from all 12 S.S. Divisions) | |
| Carson Palmer - 1st Team | QB |
| John Minardi - 1st Team | DB |
| Nick Sparks - 2nd Team | K |
| Nick Cappelletti - 2nd Team | LB |
| 1997 - Division V | |
| Jim Hartigan - Coach of the Year | Head Coach |
| Carson Palmer - Offensive MVP | QB |
| John Minardi - Defensive MVP | DB |
| Nick Sparks | K |
| Nick Cappelletti | LB |
| Ryan Mannix | OL |
| Shaun Jackson | OL |
| Bryant Wolfsberger | RB |
| Matt Strickroth | DL |
| Greg Orlando | WR |
| Jason Rowell | DL |
| 1998 - Division VI | |
| Greg Orlando | QB |
| Mike O'Gorman | WR |
| Will Watson | DL |
| Collin Rooke | DL |
| 2000 - ALL-CIF-SS TEAM (The best from all 12 S.S. Divisions) | |
| Ryan Lumm | OL |
| 2000 - Division I | |
| Tyler Thompson | RB |
| Ryan Lumm | OL |
| 2001 - Division I | |
| Michael Leiter | DL |
| Ashton White | RB |
| 2005 - Division I | |
| Tom Roby | OL |
| 2006 - Pac 5 | |
| Ryan Maxwell | DB |
| 2010 - Pac 5 | |
| Max Tuerk | OL |
| Adam Young | Utility |
| 2011 - Pac 5 | |
| Harry Welch - Coach of the Year | Head Coach |
| Johnny Stanton - Offensive MVP | QB |
| Chris Frost - Defensive MVP | DL |
| Ryan Wolpin | RB |
| Max Tuerk | OL |
| Riley Sorenson | OL |
| River Cracraft | WR |
| Connor O'Brien | DB |
| John McGrory | K |
| Mack Pierson | DL |
| 2012 - Pac 5 | |
| Dane Crane | OL |
| Riley Sorenson | OL |
| Connor O’Brien | DB |
| 2014 - Pac 5 | |
| Kyle Sweet | WR |
| 2015 - Pac 5 | |
| Alec Stewart | DL |
| 2019 - Division II | |
| Derek Wilkins | DL |
| 2021 - Division 1 | |
| Jalen Jones | WR |
| Kilian O'Conner | OL |
| Blake Wilson | DB |
| Hero Kanu | DL |
| 2022 - Division 1 | |
| Emmett Mosley | WR |
| 2023 - Division 1 | |
| Noah Sulick | LB |
| Trent Mosely | WR |
| Jacob Maiava | OL |
| 2024 - Division 1 | |
| Trent Mosely | WR |
| Dash Fifita | LB |
| Leki Holani | LB |
